New People Sharing Old Heresies

73 - New People Sharing Old Heresies

November 20, 2026•10 min read

Helping Christian parents and church leaders respond to challenging questions with biblical truth and genuine compassion.

Conversations about sexuality, marriage, and biblical teaching are becoming increasingly common—not only in politics and popular culture, but also within churches and Christian families.

Parents may hear their adult children question what Scripture teaches about same-sex relationships. Pastors may encounter members who sincerely believe that traditional Christian teaching is inconsistent with Jesus' command to love one another. Others may wonder whether certain passages of Scripture have been misunderstood or incorrectly translated.

These questions matter, and they deserve thoughtful answers.

Recently, Texas politician James Talarico discussed Christianity and homosexuality during an appearance on Joe Rogan's podcast. His comments reflected several arguments frequently raised by those who believe Christians should reconsider traditional biblical teaching on sexuality.

Christian apologist Tim Barnett, of Stand to Reason, responded through his educational video series, Red Pen Logic. Barnett's approach is particularly helpful because he takes complicated theological arguments and breaks them down into questions ordinary Christians can understand.

His response centers on four claims:

  1. Jesus never specifically addressed homosexuality.

  2. Old Testament passages about same-sex behavior are difficult to interpret and may no longer apply.

  3. Jesus summarized God's commandments as loving God and loving our neighbors, making love more important than religious rules.

  4. The word "homosexuality" did not appear in English Bible translations until relatively recently.

Each claim raises an important question about how Christians understand Scripture.

1. If Jesus Never Mentioned Homosexuality, Does That Mean He Approved of It?

One of the most common arguments is that Jesus never explicitly spoke about homosexuality.

That observation raises a reasonable question: If the subject were important, wouldn't Jesus have addressed it directly?

Barnett points out that silence does not necessarily indicate approval.

Jesus did not provide individual teachings addressing every possible moral issue. His ministry took place within a Jewish culture that already possessed an established understanding of God's law. To understand Jesus' teaching, we must therefore consider the larger biblical context.

Barnett highlights three important passages.

First, Jesus lived and taught within the Jewish understanding of Scripture.

The Old Testament law included prohibitions concerning same-sex sexual behavior in Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13. Barnett argues that Jesus' Jewish audience would have understood these teachings as part of their inherited moral framework.

Second, Jesus condemned sexual immorality.

In Mark 7:20–23, Jesus identifies sexual immorality among the sins that come from the human heart. The Greek word used in this passage is porneia, a broad term describing sexual conduct considered immoral. Barnett understands this term within the sexual ethics of the Old Testament, including its prohibitions concerning same-sex sexual behavior.

Third, Jesus affirmed the creation account when discussing marriage.

In Matthew 19:4–6, Jesus refers to Genesis, describing God's creation of male and female and the union of husband and wife. Barnett argues that Jesus' appeal to Genesis reinforces the biblical understanding of marriage as the union of one man and one woman.

Christians who affirm same-sex marriage interpret some of these passages differently, particularly regarding whether Jesus' teaching on divorce establishes an exclusive definition of marriage. Nevertheless, Barnett's response illustrates why traditional Christian teaching draws upon the whole of Scripture rather than relying only on statements directly attributed to Jesus.

2. Do Old Testament Commands Still Apply to Christians?

Another frequently raised question concerns the laws found in Leviticus. The Old Testament contains instructions about food, clothing, agriculture, worship, and sexual behavior. Since Christians do not observe many of those regulations today, why should certain sexual prohibitions remain relevant?

Barnett explains that Christians have historically distinguished between laws given specifically to ancient Israel and moral commands understood to reflect God's enduring standards.

For example, the Old Testament included dietary and ceremonial regulations that distinguished Israel from surrounding nations.

Other commands addressed conduct such as murder, adultery, and sexual immorality.

Traditional Christian theology generally understands these moral principles as still significant, particularly where the New Testament reaffirms them. Barnett argues that the biblical prohibitions concerning same-sex sexual behavior belong within this enduring moral framework.

He also challenges the suggestion that the wording in Leviticus is so unclear that its meaning cannot be determined. Although translating ancient languages requires careful scholarship, Barnett maintains that the passages in question are reasonably straightforward.

For Christians seeking to understand these questions, the important principle is to examine the passages carefully rather than assuming that all Old Testament commands either apply equally today or have become irrelevant. Faithful biblical interpretation requires context, consistency, and a willingness to understand what Scripture actually says.

3. Didn't Jesus Tell Us Simply to Love One Another?

Perhaps the most emotionally compelling argument concerns Jesus' command to love.

In Matthew 22:37–40, Jesus summarizes the law through two great commandments: love God and love your neighbor. Some Christians understand this emphasis on love as a reason to reconsider traditional teachings about same-sex relationships. They ask: If two people genuinely love one another, shouldn't Christians celebrate that relationship rather than oppose it?

This question often comes from sincere concern for people who have experienced rejection, loneliness, or mistreatment.

Jesus consistently demonstrated compassion toward people who were overlooked, rejected, or condemned by others. He challenged religious hypocrisy and confronted those who used religious rules without demonstrating mercy. However, Barnett emphasizes that Jesus did not present love and obedience as competing priorities. Instead, he argues that God's commands help us understand what genuine love requires.

In John 14:15, Jesus connects love for Him with obedience to His commandments. Similarly, 1 Corinthians 13:6 teaches that love rejoices with the truth. From the traditional Christian perspective, loving another person does not mean affirming every decision or behavior.

At the same time, disagreeing with someone's choices never gives Christians permission to treat that person without dignity, kindness, or respect. Barnett himself acknowledges the importance of loving LGBTQ-identified neighbors because every person bears God's image and possesses inherent worth.

What Does This Look Like in Everyday Life?

For parents, loving a son or daughter who identifies as gay may involve listening carefully, maintaining a meaningful relationship, and demonstrating that parental love is not conditional upon agreement.

For pastors, it means welcoming individuals into genuine relationships within the church while communicating the congregation's biblical convictions with clarity and humility.

For other believers, it means refusing to reduce people to a political issue, sexual attraction, or identity label.

Christians can hold traditional beliefs about marriage while recognizing that every individual deserves compassion and respect. Biblical conviction should never become an excuse for cruelty, and compassion should never require dishonesty about what we believe Scripture teaches. This is the balance Christian families and churches must continually seek.

4. Was the Word "Homosexuality" Added to the Bible?

Another argument gaining attention online concerns the history of Bible translation.

The English word homosexuality is relatively modern and did not exist when the biblical texts were written. Does that mean the Bible's references to same-sex behavior were introduced by later translators?

Barnett responds by explaining an important distinction between ancient languages and modern translations.

Every English Bible contains words that did not exist when the original Hebrew and Greek manuscripts were written. The relevant question is whether those English words accurately communicate the meaning of the original text.

In 1 Corinthians 6:9, the apostle Paul uses the Greek term arsenokoitai.

Barnett explains that this word appears to combine terms associated with males and sexual relations. He also notes its apparent connection to language found in the Greek translation of Leviticus.

Barnett supports the traditional interpretation that Paul was addressing sexual behavior between males. However, he also makes an important observation about modern translations. Today, words such as gay and homosexual often describe a person's identity or pattern of attraction. The ancient biblical writers did not use these modern identity categories in the same way.

For that reason, Barnett argues that translating the passage in terms of specific behavior can be clearer than using a modern identity label.

This distinction is particularly helpful for Christian parents and church leaders. Experiencing a particular attraction (temptation), identifying with that attraction, and choosing to engage in sexual behavior are not identical concepts. Recognizing these differences can lead to more accurate biblical teaching and more compassionate conversations.

Why These Questions Matter for Christian Families

For many Christians past their forties, cultural attitudes toward sexuality have changed dramatically during their lifetimes. Ideas that were once rarely discussed publicly are now part of everyday conversations in schools, workplaces, entertainment, and churches. Parents may discover that their children have adopted beliefs about sexuality that differ significantly from those they were taught. Church leaders may encounter members who are uncertain whether traditional biblical teaching remains relevant. Simply repeating a familiar position may not be enough to help someone understand why Christians believe it.

We need to be prepared to explain our convictions thoughtfully.

First Peter 3:15 instructs believers to be ready to give a reason for their hope, while doing so with gentleness and respect.

That instruction provides an excellent foundation for approaching difficult conversations. We should be willing to listen, ask questions, study Scripture, and acknowledge where genuine disagreements about interpretation exist.

We should also resist the temptation to assume that everyone who questions traditional Christian teaching is rejecting God or acting in bad faith. Some people are genuinely trying to reconcile their understanding of Scripture with their experiences, relationships, and concern for others. Those conversations require patience.

Helping the Next Generation Understand Biblical Truth

One of the most important responsibilities of Christian parents and church leaders is helping younger generations develop a thoughtful understanding of their faith. That means doing more than telling them what Christians believe, we need to help them understand why.

When a young adult asks why Christians believe marriage is between a man and a woman, we should be prepared to discuss the biblical foundation for that conviction.

When someone asks why certain Old Testament commands are followed while others are not, we should be willing to explain how Christians understand the relationship between the Old and New Testaments.

And when someone asks whether biblical teaching is compatible with genuine love, our response should reflect the character of Christ.

These discussions should not become arguments in which winning matters more than the person sitting across from us. Our purpose is to help people encounter biblical truth and understand the hope of the gospel found in Jesus.

That requires humility, wisdom, and a willingness to build relationships strong enough to sustain difficult conversations.

Holding Grace and Truth Together

Tim Barnett's Red Pen Logic videos offer Christians an accessible way to examine arguments about Scripture and consider how those arguments hold up under careful questioning. His response to James Talarico illustrates why biblical interpretation requires more than repeating familiar cultural phrases.

Questions about Jesus' teaching, Old Testament law, love, and Bible translation deserve thoughtful examination, yet there is an even greater responsibility for the Church. We must demonstrate that biblical truth and genuine compassion belong together.

Jesus never treated truth as unimportant, nor did He approach people without compassion.

John 1:14 describes Him as full of grace and truth.

Christians are called to follow that example.

Parents should be able to discuss difficult subjects without making their children afraid to ask questions.

Pastors should be able to teach biblical convictions without losing sight of the people affected by those teachings.

And every Christian should remember that the gospel is not simply a collection of moral instructions.

It is the good news of God's love, mercy, forgiveness, and transforming grace through Jesus Christ.


Sources and Further Reading

  1. Tim Barnett — Stand to Reason: Biography and ministry background. Barnett produces Red Pen Logic, which examines arguments about Christianity and biblical interpretation.

  2. Red Pen Logic: Tim Barnett's video response to James Talarico's comments during an interview on The Joe Rogan Experience, discussed in the original Resources4Redemption article.

  3. Resources4Redemption: Hays vs. Hays — Part I, Challenge from the Past, referenced in the original article as part of an earlier examination of arguments surrounding biblical sexual ethics.

  4. Scripture references: Genesis 2:24; Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13; Mark 7:20–23; Matthew 19:4–6; Matthew 22:37–40; John 14:15; 1 Corinthians 6:9 and 13:6; 1 Peter 3:15; John 1:14.

Adapted from this original article:New People Sharing Old Heresies – and Those who Keep up With Them, Resources4Redemption, Debra Baty, May 19, 2026

blog author avatar
Resources 4 Redemption https://resources4redemption.substack.com
Back to Blog
Love & Truth Network Logo